SimplePractice publishes tiered plans with different feature access. Carelumio’s direction is a focused workspace for US therapy practices with 1–10 clinicians. Compare what you need today with what is actually available.
By Carelumio · Vendor-authored comparison · Sources reviewed October 4, 2026
READ THIS FIRST
Compare the plan, not just the feature list.
SimplePractice details below reflect published vendor documentation. Carelumio entries describe intended scope or illustrative previews, not equivalent, verified production features. This is not an independent review or hands-on performance test.
SIDE BY SIDE
Compare what matters in your working day.
Availability, plan limits and the exact workflow matter more than a simple yes or no.
Workflow
SimplePracticeVendor-documented capabilities
CarelumioPlanned scope / verify availability
Clinical documentation
SimplePractice
Essential and Plus include customizable progress-note and treatment-plan templates. Starter has more limited template access. Source ↗
Carelumio · planned scope
Notes, assessments and treatment plans are in the intended scope; exact templates and signing workflows require confirmation.
Telehealth
SimplePractice
Listed as included on Starter, Essential and Plus. Source ↗
Carelumio · planned scope
In-person and telehealth workflows are in scope; video functionality and provider arrangements require verification.
Client communication
SimplePractice
Secure messaging is listed on Essential and Plus, but not Starter. Source ↗
Carelumio · planned scope
A connected client-communication experience is planned; confirm portal and messaging availability.
Small-team access
SimplePractice
Adding team members requires Plus. Confirm clinician and administrative-role charges. Source ↗
Carelumio · planned scope
Role-based views for 1–10 clinicians are planned, including appropriate access for an external biller.
Insurance billing
SimplePractice
Documents electronic claims, claim tracking and automatic payment recording. Confirm current transaction charges. Source ↗
Carelumio · planned scope
Insurance is planned. Payer connections, eligibility, submission and payment posting are not verified by these previews.
Practice insights
SimplePractice
Analytics and reports are listed on Essential and Plus, but not Starter. Source ↗
Carelumio · planned scope
The website shows fictional dashboard examples; live reporting is not verified.
PRICING & TOTAL COST
Budget for the way you actually work.
US dollar amounts checked October 4, 2026. Verify current pricing before purchase; these are not complete operating-cost estimates.
SimplePractice
Published subscription pricing
Starter $49/month · Essential $79/month · Plus $99/month.
Standard advertised monthly base rates, excluding temporary discounts. Additional clinicians and optional services can add to the total. The pricing page lists additional practitioners from $74/month and custom pricing discussions for groups of 6 or more.
Ask both vendors to cost the same scenario: your clinician count, monthly sessions, claims, reminders, card payments and required add-ons. Check migration and data-export terms too.
WHICH FITS YOUR PRACTICE?
Choose around your needs and your timing.
Our recommendation is to evaluate readiness first, then convenience and cost.
When to evaluate SimplePractice
Start with SimplePractice if you need an available product and one of its documented plans meets your required workflows. Pay particular attention to plan-specific access for messaging, templates, analytics and team members.
When to explore Carelumio
You run a US outpatient therapy practice with 1–10 clinicians and want to evaluate our focused daily-workspace approach. Bring your requirements to a demonstration and establish which capabilities are available before making a switching decision.
Our previews are not evidence that Carelumio is faster, easier or more complete than SimplePractice.
Book a recurring appointment, complete intake, document the visit and follow it through payment. For insurance, include a rejected claim and a corrected submission. For a group, test the permissions of a clinician, administrator and biller.
Agree what moves—and what stays accessible.
Confirm patient details, notes, attachments, balances and appointment history. Establish import limits, validation, costs and how historical records remain accessible. No direct SimplePractice integration or migration is claimed here.
Review privacy and responsibilities.
Ask both vendors for applicable agreements and security evidence. Carelumio’s HIPAA statement is a launch commitment, not a completed compliance verification.
Is Carelumio a ready-to-use SimplePractice replacement?
That is not established by this comparison. Confirm every essential capability, migration requirement and applicable agreement before using Carelumio as a replacement.
Which SimplePractice plan should I compare against?
Use the plan that includes your actual requirements, rather than automatically comparing the lowest advertised price. For a group, include additional clinicians and any relevant role or add-on charges.
Can I keep my external biller?
Discuss how your biller will access records, submit claims and return payment information. Carelumio includes this arrangement in its planned scope, but the precise access and integrations need verification.
SOURCES & METHOD
Check the details at the source.
We reviewed public vendor pages on October 4, 2026. We selected workflows relevant to solo and small outpatient therapy practices; this is not an exhaustive feature inventory. Features, plans and prices may change.
Carelumio information comes from our current product scope and illustrative website views. Competitor names belong to their respective owners; no affiliation or endorsement is implied.